Godavari: The New Narmada?
Will Polavaram be another ecocide zone? Not if we apply the Vedanta logic to it.
Godavari Flow Chart
* 80 TMC of water diverted to river Krishna. Water supply to Visakhapatnam. Drinking water to 540 villages.
* Will irrigate 2.91 lakh hectares. Power generation: 960 MW
* Full reservoir Level: 151 feet, total cost: about Rs 17,800 crore
* Clearance from MoEF in July 2010
* Environmentalists and rights activists say the dam could inundate parts of AP, Orissa and Chhattisgarh, swamp 280 villages. It will displace two lakh people, mostly tribals.
***
The Polavaram dam across the river Godavari has been a dream project for several governments in Andhra Pradesh. Most of them had to let it stay at that—a dream. An ambitious project which envisages harnessing the river’s surplus water that otherwise flows into the sea (80 thousand million cubic feet is also diverted annually to the Krishna river), the Polavaram dam has been in the conceptual stage since 1943. It was only when Y.S. Rajasekhara Reddy took charge and accorded irrigation topmost priority that the dam’s construction was taken up as part of the Jalayagnam programme.
Christened the Indira Sagar Polavaram project, the 151-ft-high dam will have a gross storage capacity of 194.6 TMC and a power generation capacity of 960 MW. However, the dam has remained controversial from the word go. One of the major issues is the massive submergence of forest and cultivated land it will entail in Khammam, the west and east Godavari districts, Chhattisgarh and Orissa. Up to 40,138 hectares will be affected, uprooting a population of two lakh, many of them primitive tribal groups and adivasis. In all, 280 villages would be hit. Besides, reserve forests and a part of the Papikonda wildlife sanctuary would cease to exist. However, regardless of all this, the Union ministry of environment and forests (MOEF) cleared the proposal for diversion of 3,731.07 hectares of forest land for the Indira Sagar project in July 2010. While the AP government celebrates it as an achievement, tribal activists and environmentalists see red.
Madhusudhan N., who runs ngo Yakshi and works for tribal rights, says the logic which the Saxena committee report used to nullify Vedanta’s project in Orissa should apply here as well. “The MOEF’s clearance is based on the assurance by the AP government that there are no forest rights to be settled under the Scheduled Tribes and Other Forest Dwellers (Recognition of Forest Right) Act, 2006, in the project area. The fact is that several tribals like Koyas and Konda Reddies have been living here for long. Their cultural ecosystems, their territorial rights to forest resources need to be recognised. In other words, they cannot be evicted. The AP government has obviously misled the Centre on these facts.”
S. Jeevan Kumar, president, Human Rights Forum, calls the dam a hugely destructive project. “Tribals and Dalits,” he says, “will account for 65 per cent of the displaced. The natural resources, cultural systems, traditional knowledge of these people are closely tied to the land they inhabit. With no forest, the existence of these communities will become untenable. Another condition for the MOEF’s clearance is that the consent of gram sabhas (village councils) has to be obtained. Not a single gram sabha has given its consent so far. The Centre cannot apply the Forest Rights Act, 2006, selectively only in Orissa and ignore it in AP.” Both the Orissa and Chhattisgarh governments have gone to the Supreme Court seeking a stay on the dam.
Hind Site Work on the main canal
Irrigation and environment expert Prof T. Shivaji Rao says the dam is being built by blindly ignoring aspects like climate change and global warming. “Over the years, the intensity and duration of storms in the Godavari are going to increase by 20-30 per cent. The AP government cannot alter nature.” He points out that the National Institute of Hydrology, Roorkee, had in 1999 said the maximum flood inflow in the Godavari could be 60 lakh cusecs. The Central Water Commission (CWC) was only slightly more conservative: it put the figure at 50 lakh cusecs in September 2006. “Even if one were to take CWC’s figure, the Polavaram dam would be a ticking time-bomb during floods,” says Shivaji Rao.
Union Nations consultant for Asian irrigation projects, T. Hanumantha Rao, while factoring in these climate change facts, had suggested an alternative to the Polavaram dam in the form of three barrages at Polavaram, between Bhadrachalam and Konavaram and across the Sabari river close to the Orissa border. The AP government ruled out his proposals. “They were technically unviable,” says irrigation minister Ponnala Laxmaiah. Hanumantha Rao says that he has never been against the Polavaram project but these barrages might just present a solution and work out cheaper than the current cost of Rs 17,728.20 crore and will generate more power (1,038 MW).
Both Shivaji Rao and Hanumantha Rao point out that earthen dams are prone to breaches. Since the soil foundation at Polavaram is of clay and sand, a concrete dam is unviable. Other major rivers in the world which have lesser peak flood discharges than Godavari, such as the Yangtze in China, the Mississippi in the US or the Volga in Russia, do not have earthen dams at locations where such high flood flow conditions occur. The Indira Sagar project is located almost at the end of the river where the peak discharge occurs.
Shivaji Rao points out: “In October 2009, the Krishna river saw unprecedented floods, more than 2.7 times the normal flow, and Kurnool was submerged for days together. And there is no dam out there. If such a situation occurs in the Godavari and the Polavaram dam is built, then a breach is almost certain. The maximum flood inflow would be 90 lakh cusecs. Imagine a tsunami of 200 TMC of dam water breaking across the Godavari delta. Overnight, 45 lakh people would have a watery grave.”
Irrigation officials in the government dismiss these theories as alarmist and say that the benefits of the Polavaram dam are too many to be ignored. Irrigation minister Laxmaiah says that the objections by Orissa and Chhattisgarh have no relevance since they are signatories to the 1976 Bachawat Award on the Krishna waters. “We have obtained all the clearances and are offering a compensation package of more than Rs 600 crore for the two states. We are offering the best rehabilitation and relief packages in the country,” says Laxmaiah. “In fact, we invited Medha Patkar about four years back to assess the R&R package and she found it to be good. The government has also taken the suggestions of the World Water Forum.” Do the people have a say, that is the moot question.
This blog tries to explore the lives of rivers and their inter-dependence with the basin communities and ecosystems in a holistic perspectives. It seeks to share the influences of changing natural and anthropogenic processes on the river-scapes and how the resultant changes in river-scapes influence the livelihoods and ecosystems. Taking an integrated approach of river-basin management, it aims to enhance basin-literacy by linking the processes in river-scape, land-scape and human-scape.
Wednesday, September 8, 2010
Polavaram
Labels:
Dams/Reservoirs,
displacement,
Industry,
Inter-state,
Odisha,
Polavaram,
water conflict
Sunday, September 5, 2010
Polavaram Politics
Final approval for Polavaram project erroneous: Orissa
J. Venkatesan
Deliberate act to render suit infructuous
NEW DELHI: The Orissa government moved the Supreme Court on Saturday seeking a stay on the final approval granted by the Union Environment and Forests Ministry for the Indira Sagar (Polavaram) Project in Andhra Pradesh, and a direction for status quo.
On Wednesday, the Centre, in response to Orissa's suit, justified the grant of clearance for execution of the project. It said protection against submergence had been provided and allayed Chief Minister Naveen Patnaik's apprehensions.
Conditions same
In its fresh application, Orissa argued that the conditions stipulated in the approval letter were similar to the one issued in 2009 for grant of in-principle approval. When the 2009 approval was still pending in court, the grant of the final approval on the same conditions would amount to overreaching the Supreme Court's orders and interference in its proceedings.
Assailing the Centre for granting approval without informing Orissa, the application pointed out that the project on an inter-State river was fraught with the serious consequences of submergence of, and an adverse environmental impact on, the territories of Orissa. Mr. Patnaik had written to Prime Minister Manmohan Singh and the Ministry seeking withdrawal of the clearance granted on July 28. In its reply, the Ministry said clearance was granted after “due care of the issues raised” was taken.
Wrong assumption
Drawing a distinction between the original and revised proposals, the application said Orissa entered into the 1980 agreement with Andhra Pradesh based on the maximum backwater level of 174.22 feet for a maximum discharge of 36 lakh cusecs, as put forth by Andhra Pradesh.
However, as per the Andhra Pradesh government's application to the Environment Ministry, the backwater would go up to 182 feet for a discharge of 36 lakh cusecs. Therefore, the most fundamental assumption of fact on which the agreement had been entered into turned out to be wrong.
Furthermore, Andhra Pradesh should have executed the Inchampalli joint project first, so that the design flood at Polavaram could have been drastically reduced to 36 lakh cusecs or lower.
The Inchampalli project was not executed though the agreement had been made in 1975.
In the absence of the revised reservoir operation schedule, due to the change in the design flood, in consultation with the co-basin States of Chhattisgarh and Orissa, the permission and approval granted by the Union Ministry was erroneous and liable to be quashed. The grant of approval was a deliberate act to render the suit infructuous, the application said.
J. Venkatesan
Deliberate act to render suit infructuous
NEW DELHI: The Orissa government moved the Supreme Court on Saturday seeking a stay on the final approval granted by the Union Environment and Forests Ministry for the Indira Sagar (Polavaram) Project in Andhra Pradesh, and a direction for status quo.
On Wednesday, the Centre, in response to Orissa's suit, justified the grant of clearance for execution of the project. It said protection against submergence had been provided and allayed Chief Minister Naveen Patnaik's apprehensions.
Conditions same
In its fresh application, Orissa argued that the conditions stipulated in the approval letter were similar to the one issued in 2009 for grant of in-principle approval. When the 2009 approval was still pending in court, the grant of the final approval on the same conditions would amount to overreaching the Supreme Court's orders and interference in its proceedings.
Assailing the Centre for granting approval without informing Orissa, the application pointed out that the project on an inter-State river was fraught with the serious consequences of submergence of, and an adverse environmental impact on, the territories of Orissa. Mr. Patnaik had written to Prime Minister Manmohan Singh and the Ministry seeking withdrawal of the clearance granted on July 28. In its reply, the Ministry said clearance was granted after “due care of the issues raised” was taken.
Wrong assumption
Drawing a distinction between the original and revised proposals, the application said Orissa entered into the 1980 agreement with Andhra Pradesh based on the maximum backwater level of 174.22 feet for a maximum discharge of 36 lakh cusecs, as put forth by Andhra Pradesh.
However, as per the Andhra Pradesh government's application to the Environment Ministry, the backwater would go up to 182 feet for a discharge of 36 lakh cusecs. Therefore, the most fundamental assumption of fact on which the agreement had been entered into turned out to be wrong.
Furthermore, Andhra Pradesh should have executed the Inchampalli joint project first, so that the design flood at Polavaram could have been drastically reduced to 36 lakh cusecs or lower.
The Inchampalli project was not executed though the agreement had been made in 1975.
In the absence of the revised reservoir operation schedule, due to the change in the design flood, in consultation with the co-basin States of Chhattisgarh and Orissa, the permission and approval granted by the Union Ministry was erroneous and liable to be quashed. The grant of approval was a deliberate act to render the suit infructuous, the application said.
Polavaram Politics
Orissa moves SC over Polavaram
BS Reporter / Bhubaneswar September 06, 2010, 0:49 IST
Continuing its protest over the Rs 10,000-crore Polavaram power project on the Godavari river in neighbouring Andhra Pradesh, the Orissa government has filed a petition in the Supreme Court opposing the Centre’s decision to give an environmental nod for the controversial project.
“In our petition in the Supreme Court, we have demanded the cancellation of the environmental clearance given to the project by the Union Ministry of Environment and Forests (MoEF) to the Polavaram project. The state government has argued as to how the ministry could give the clearance when a case related to the project is already pending in the apex court,” Suresh Mohapatra, secretary (water resources), told Business Standard. According to state government estimates, the project was likely to submerge 2119.38 hectares of land in the Naxalite-affected tribal areas of Malkangiri district.
The Orissa government had first moved the Supreme Court after MoEF had given its interim approval for the project in 2008.
Now, it has sought a declaration that Andhra Pradesh had no right or entitlement to undertake or proceed with the project on the Godavari river. It has also stated that embankments were not permanent solutions to effectively contain submergence during floods.
The Orissa government has also accused the Central Water Commission of not furnishing any details before approving the project.
The filing of the petition in the apex court comes on the heels of Chief Minister Naveen Patnaik’s statement that Orissa would continue to oppose the Polavaram project, owing to its concerns of submergence of tribal villages and forest land.
BS Reporter / Bhubaneswar September 06, 2010, 0:49 IST
Continuing its protest over the Rs 10,000-crore Polavaram power project on the Godavari river in neighbouring Andhra Pradesh, the Orissa government has filed a petition in the Supreme Court opposing the Centre’s decision to give an environmental nod for the controversial project.
“In our petition in the Supreme Court, we have demanded the cancellation of the environmental clearance given to the project by the Union Ministry of Environment and Forests (MoEF) to the Polavaram project. The state government has argued as to how the ministry could give the clearance when a case related to the project is already pending in the apex court,” Suresh Mohapatra, secretary (water resources), told Business Standard. According to state government estimates, the project was likely to submerge 2119.38 hectares of land in the Naxalite-affected tribal areas of Malkangiri district.
The Orissa government had first moved the Supreme Court after MoEF had given its interim approval for the project in 2008.
Now, it has sought a declaration that Andhra Pradesh had no right or entitlement to undertake or proceed with the project on the Godavari river. It has also stated that embankments were not permanent solutions to effectively contain submergence during floods.
The Orissa government has also accused the Central Water Commission of not furnishing any details before approving the project.
The filing of the petition in the apex court comes on the heels of Chief Minister Naveen Patnaik’s statement that Orissa would continue to oppose the Polavaram project, owing to its concerns of submergence of tribal villages and forest land.
Friday, September 3, 2010
SANDRP on Polavaram
Sept 2 2010
From:
Himanshu Thakkar
South Asia Network on Dams, Rivers & People,�
c/o 86-D, AD block, Shalimar Bagh,
Delhi,�himanshuthakkar@iitbombay.org, ht.sandrp@gmail.com�www.sandrp.in
Ph: 27484655/ 9968242798 9968242798
To: Shri Jairam Ramesh
Union Minister of State for Env and Forests (IC), New Delhi
Respected Sir,
I have just seen your letter dated Aug 18, 2010 to�Orissa�Chief�Minister on the aboves subject, uploaded yesterday on MEF website.�
1. Your letter says that the Forest Clearance has been given to the Polavaram Project on July 28, 2010 is subject to the condition, "... no submergence and displacement of people including STs take place in Orissa and Chhattisgarh...". However, this condition is in complete contradiction with the environment clearance given by your ministry on Oct 25, 2005, which says in para 2, "Total 1,93,35 persons are likely to be affected by this project, out of that 1,75,275 persons in Andhra Pradesh and 6,316 persons from Orissa and 11,766 are from Chattisgarh."�It is clear the condition of no submergence and displacement on Orissa and Chhattisgarh, stated in your letter, in the Tribal Development Ministry's condition, and in the forest clearance letter is in complete contradiction with the environment clearance given by you. One of them have to be cancelled due to this contradiction, we would like to know, which one would be cancelled.�
2. This condition of no submergence or displacement in Orissa or Chhattisgarh is based on the proposal to construct embankments along the respective rivers in Orissa and Chhattisgarh. However, the proposal to construct these embankments was not part of the project that was given clearance by your ministry on Oct 25, 2005. This change in scope of the project came to light when the project went for CWC clearance (given on 23.01.2009 following flawed in principle forest clearance given by your ministry on Dec 26, 2008). Following letter from MEF, the Govt of AP applied for concurrence of the MEF for building embankments on 29.01.2009. The issue came up for discussion in the meeting of EAC of River Valley committee on Feb 16-17, 2009. Prior to this EAC meeting, we had sent a detailed letter on 13.02.2009 to the EAC, explaining the implications of the proposal, lack of EIA or public consultation process, how this changes the scope of the project and so on, the same is attached. It is clear from details of this letter that hundred of ha of land would be required in Orissa and Chhattisgarh for the building of embankments, for mining of materials for building of embankments, for leaving land on the banks of the river on both sides, for building approach road, for building cross drainage channels and so on. A very large portion of this land would be forest land and it would also imply displacement of the people and their livelihoods. This itself is sufficient ground to show that MOTA condition, Orissa HC condition, your condition and FC condition of no submergence and displacement in Orissa and Chhattisgarh is impossible to adhere to, and this should again be sufficient ground to cancel both the priliminary and final FC given by your minister.�
3. After the EAC meeting of Feb 16-17 2009, the EAC decided on this issue, "The EAC therefore directed the project proponent to initiate suitable action requesting the appropriate authorities in Orissa & Chattisgarh for conducting public hearings in the respective states of Chattisgarh & Orissa in respect of embankment proposal and report back to the committee."�I am attaching the minutes of this EAC meeting for ready reference. This decision of the EAC implies that the project needs fresh clearance for this component and since project without this component would violate the various legal norms and conditions the project also cannot go ahead without that. However, the project is yet to take these steps and if it were to take this steps it would violate your conditions of no submergence and displacement in Orissa and Chhattisgarh. It is clear that your condition of no submergence and displacement in Orissa and Chhattisgarh is impossible to adhere to and hence the FC of the project has to be cancelled.�
4. Here we would like to add that the EAC decision in Feb 16-17 2009 meeting was flawed since it is clear that this was changing the scope of the project cleared earlier. So EAC should also have asked that the earlier EC be cancelled till this decision is followed.�
5. The Forest clearance given by your ministry, incidentally, has a condition, namely no (x), which says, "The project authority shall maintain flow of water in the down-stream course of river equal to the normal flow of water existing in pre-dam condition". I am at a loss to understand if this condition is to be adhered to (and I assume it needs to be adhered to all round the year, in all years, since there are no qualifications in the condition), how can the dam be built or operated at all? It seems there has not been sufficient application of mind while according �the final FC dated 28.7.2010, which is sufficient reason for its cancellation.�
These objections to the final FC and narration of the contradictions in your letter actually gives an opportunity to revisit the project �and look for better options in achieving the irrigation and water supply in project areas. Hope you will take necessary steps in that direction after cancelling the flawed Environment clearance of Oct 25, 2005 (which was also quashed by NEAA in Dec 2007) and the forest clearances of Dec 26, 2008 and July 28, 2010.�
I would be happy to explain these issues if necessary and will look forward to your early response.�
Thanking you,
Himanshu Thakkar
From:
Himanshu Thakkar
South Asia Network on Dams, Rivers & People,�
c/o 86-D, AD block, Shalimar Bagh,
Delhi,�himanshuthakkar@iitbombay.org, ht.sandrp@gmail.com�www.sandrp.in
Ph: 27484655/ 9968242798 9968242798
To: Shri Jairam Ramesh
Union Minister of State for Env and Forests (IC), New Delhi
Respected Sir,
I have just seen your letter dated Aug 18, 2010 to�Orissa�Chief�Minister on the aboves subject, uploaded yesterday on MEF website.�
1. Your letter says that the Forest Clearance has been given to the Polavaram Project on July 28, 2010 is subject to the condition, "... no submergence and displacement of people including STs take place in Orissa and Chhattisgarh...". However, this condition is in complete contradiction with the environment clearance given by your ministry on Oct 25, 2005, which says in para 2, "Total 1,93,35 persons are likely to be affected by this project, out of that 1,75,275 persons in Andhra Pradesh and 6,316 persons from Orissa and 11,766 are from Chattisgarh."�It is clear the condition of no submergence and displacement on Orissa and Chhattisgarh, stated in your letter, in the Tribal Development Ministry's condition, and in the forest clearance letter is in complete contradiction with the environment clearance given by you. One of them have to be cancelled due to this contradiction, we would like to know, which one would be cancelled.�
2. This condition of no submergence or displacement in Orissa or Chhattisgarh is based on the proposal to construct embankments along the respective rivers in Orissa and Chhattisgarh. However, the proposal to construct these embankments was not part of the project that was given clearance by your ministry on Oct 25, 2005. This change in scope of the project came to light when the project went for CWC clearance (given on 23.01.2009 following flawed in principle forest clearance given by your ministry on Dec 26, 2008). Following letter from MEF, the Govt of AP applied for concurrence of the MEF for building embankments on 29.01.2009. The issue came up for discussion in the meeting of EAC of River Valley committee on Feb 16-17, 2009. Prior to this EAC meeting, we had sent a detailed letter on 13.02.2009 to the EAC, explaining the implications of the proposal, lack of EIA or public consultation process, how this changes the scope of the project and so on, the same is attached. It is clear from details of this letter that hundred of ha of land would be required in Orissa and Chhattisgarh for the building of embankments, for mining of materials for building of embankments, for leaving land on the banks of the river on both sides, for building approach road, for building cross drainage channels and so on. A very large portion of this land would be forest land and it would also imply displacement of the people and their livelihoods. This itself is sufficient ground to show that MOTA condition, Orissa HC condition, your condition and FC condition of no submergence and displacement in Orissa and Chhattisgarh is impossible to adhere to, and this should again be sufficient ground to cancel both the priliminary and final FC given by your minister.�
3. After the EAC meeting of Feb 16-17 2009, the EAC decided on this issue, "The EAC therefore directed the project proponent to initiate suitable action requesting the appropriate authorities in Orissa & Chattisgarh for conducting public hearings in the respective states of Chattisgarh & Orissa in respect of embankment proposal and report back to the committee."�I am attaching the minutes of this EAC meeting for ready reference. This decision of the EAC implies that the project needs fresh clearance for this component and since project without this component would violate the various legal norms and conditions the project also cannot go ahead without that. However, the project is yet to take these steps and if it were to take this steps it would violate your conditions of no submergence and displacement in Orissa and Chhattisgarh. It is clear that your condition of no submergence and displacement in Orissa and Chhattisgarh is impossible to adhere to and hence the FC of the project has to be cancelled.�
4. Here we would like to add that the EAC decision in Feb 16-17 2009 meeting was flawed since it is clear that this was changing the scope of the project cleared earlier. So EAC should also have asked that the earlier EC be cancelled till this decision is followed.�
5. The Forest clearance given by your ministry, incidentally, has a condition, namely no (x), which says, "The project authority shall maintain flow of water in the down-stream course of river equal to the normal flow of water existing in pre-dam condition". I am at a loss to understand if this condition is to be adhered to (and I assume it needs to be adhered to all round the year, in all years, since there are no qualifications in the condition), how can the dam be built or operated at all? It seems there has not been sufficient application of mind while according �the final FC dated 28.7.2010, which is sufficient reason for its cancellation.�
These objections to the final FC and narration of the contradictions in your letter actually gives an opportunity to revisit the project �and look for better options in achieving the irrigation and water supply in project areas. Hope you will take necessary steps in that direction after cancelling the flawed Environment clearance of Oct 25, 2005 (which was also quashed by NEAA in Dec 2007) and the forest clearances of Dec 26, 2008 and July 28, 2010.�
I would be happy to explain these issues if necessary and will look forward to your early response.�
Thanking you,
Himanshu Thakkar
Labels:
displacement,
Embankments,
Inter-state,
Odisha,
Polavaram
Polavaram Politics
Centre allays Orissa's fears over Polavaram project
J. Venkatesan
Affidavit justifies go-ahead for A.P. irrigation project
A.P. will build embankments with drainage arrangements
Embankments are not permanent solutions: Orissa
New Delhi: The Centre has justified in the Supreme Court the grant of clearance for the Polavaram project in Andhra Pradesh, and said protection against submergence would be ensured.
In its response to the suit filed by Orissa seeking suspension of work on the Polavaram Indira Sagar Project, the Central Water Commission (CWC), in its affidavit filed on Wednesday, said the final award of the Godavari Water Disputes Tribunal in 1980 had settled all issues of submergence.
The Centre noted that the Environment and Forests Ministry had accepted the project proposal in January 2009, asking Andhra Pradesh to ensure that there was no submergence of any habitation or forest area in Orissa and Chhattisgarh. Andhra Pradesh would construct embankments with adequate drainage arrangements to prevent submergence from backwater effect as well as reservoir submergence and consequent displacement of people in the two neighbouring States.
Multipurpose
The Centre said the Polavaram project was conceived as a multipurpose scheme providing irrigation to 4.36 lakh hectares, water supply to towns and villages en route, and generating hydel power with an installed capacity of 960 MW. The project envisaged construction of an earth-cum-rockfill dam. It fulfilled the criteria for being called a national project, and investment clearance was given by the Planning Commission in February 2009.
Allaying Orissa's fears of submergence due to floods, the Centre said the Probable Maximum Flood (PMF) estimated for the project was 1, 41,435 cumecs (about 50 lakh cusecs) was in order. The proposed spillway was capable was disposing of the PMF, and dam safety had been checked for this condition.
The Centre said Andhra Pradesh had been asked to furnish a confirmation report that there was no change in the number of project-affected Scheduled Tribe families from what was reported at the time of clearance of the Relief and Rehabilitation Plan, and that all protective steps had been taken to prevent submergence.
‘No details from CWC'
In its suit, Orissa had sought a declaration that Andhra Pradesh had no right or entitlement to undertake or proceed with the Polavaram project on the Godavari. It faulted the CWC for not furnishing any detail before approving the project. Embankments were not permanent solutions to effectively contain submergence during floods.
Also, the extent of submergence due to design flood (which had been revised to 50 lakh cusecs from the original 36 lakh cusecs by the CWC itself) and the backwater effect along the Sabari and Sileru limbs (flowing through Orissa territory into the Godavari in Andhra Pradesh) had been finalised by the CWC without estimating the flood contributions from these limbs separately by following any rational procedure or acceptable norm, Orissa said. It said the project was likely to submerge 2119.38 hectares of land in Naxalite-affected tribal areas of Malkangiri district.
J. Venkatesan
Affidavit justifies go-ahead for A.P. irrigation project
A.P. will build embankments with drainage arrangements
Embankments are not permanent solutions: Orissa
New Delhi: The Centre has justified in the Supreme Court the grant of clearance for the Polavaram project in Andhra Pradesh, and said protection against submergence would be ensured.
In its response to the suit filed by Orissa seeking suspension of work on the Polavaram Indira Sagar Project, the Central Water Commission (CWC), in its affidavit filed on Wednesday, said the final award of the Godavari Water Disputes Tribunal in 1980 had settled all issues of submergence.
The Centre noted that the Environment and Forests Ministry had accepted the project proposal in January 2009, asking Andhra Pradesh to ensure that there was no submergence of any habitation or forest area in Orissa and Chhattisgarh. Andhra Pradesh would construct embankments with adequate drainage arrangements to prevent submergence from backwater effect as well as reservoir submergence and consequent displacement of people in the two neighbouring States.
Multipurpose
The Centre said the Polavaram project was conceived as a multipurpose scheme providing irrigation to 4.36 lakh hectares, water supply to towns and villages en route, and generating hydel power with an installed capacity of 960 MW. The project envisaged construction of an earth-cum-rockfill dam. It fulfilled the criteria for being called a national project, and investment clearance was given by the Planning Commission in February 2009.
Allaying Orissa's fears of submergence due to floods, the Centre said the Probable Maximum Flood (PMF) estimated for the project was 1, 41,435 cumecs (about 50 lakh cusecs) was in order. The proposed spillway was capable was disposing of the PMF, and dam safety had been checked for this condition.
The Centre said Andhra Pradesh had been asked to furnish a confirmation report that there was no change in the number of project-affected Scheduled Tribe families from what was reported at the time of clearance of the Relief and Rehabilitation Plan, and that all protective steps had been taken to prevent submergence.
‘No details from CWC'
In its suit, Orissa had sought a declaration that Andhra Pradesh had no right or entitlement to undertake or proceed with the Polavaram project on the Godavari. It faulted the CWC for not furnishing any detail before approving the project. Embankments were not permanent solutions to effectively contain submergence during floods.
Also, the extent of submergence due to design flood (which had been revised to 50 lakh cusecs from the original 36 lakh cusecs by the CWC itself) and the backwater effect along the Sabari and Sileru limbs (flowing through Orissa territory into the Godavari in Andhra Pradesh) had been finalised by the CWC without estimating the flood contributions from these limbs separately by following any rational procedure or acceptable norm, Orissa said. It said the project was likely to submerge 2119.38 hectares of land in Naxalite-affected tribal areas of Malkangiri district.
Thursday, September 2, 2010
State's ‘attitude' on river waters flayed
Staff Reporter
BHUBANESWAR: The Southern Orissa Development Council (SODC), a people's forum, here on Wednesday launched a scathing attack on the State government for its alleged indifferent approach to utlising river water.
The criticism came in wake of possibility of submergence of more than 20 villages in Orissa by Polavaram project of Andhra Pradesh. Addressing a press conference here, Dayanidhi Sahoo, president of SODC, said successive governments in Orissa had failed to realise potential of rivers passing through southern districts and as a result Andhra Pradesh was planning project after project using runoff water from Orissa rivers, it said.
SODC demanded establishment of Water Resource Development Authority for Rushikulya, Vanshadhara, Nagabali, Kolab and Indravati rivers.
“River Godavari in Andrha Pradesh is enriched by water from the rivers like Machakund, Sileru, Potteru, Saptadhara-Kolab-Saveri which originate from mountains of Koraput.
Had Orissa government been serious on protesting against Polavaram project, it should have started irrigation projects the upstream,” the SODC president said.
Now the State was facing imminent threat of getting affected by Indira Sagar project at Polavaram. “Under present circumstances, leaders irrespective of party lines should get united and oppose the project,” he said.
Similarly, although Indravati was flowing in many parts of Nabrangpur district, agriculture there remained dependant on rain, Mr. Sahoo said. He said the Orissa government was not focusing its attention on preventing water from flowing into Andhra Pradesh and Chhattisgarh.
Situation was similar on rivers such as Mahendratanaya, Jhanjavati and Vanshadhara, Mr. Sahoo sai.d
Staff Reporter
BHUBANESWAR: The Southern Orissa Development Council (SODC), a people's forum, here on Wednesday launched a scathing attack on the State government for its alleged indifferent approach to utlising river water.
The criticism came in wake of possibility of submergence of more than 20 villages in Orissa by Polavaram project of Andhra Pradesh. Addressing a press conference here, Dayanidhi Sahoo, president of SODC, said successive governments in Orissa had failed to realise potential of rivers passing through southern districts and as a result Andhra Pradesh was planning project after project using runoff water from Orissa rivers, it said.
SODC demanded establishment of Water Resource Development Authority for Rushikulya, Vanshadhara, Nagabali, Kolab and Indravati rivers.
“River Godavari in Andrha Pradesh is enriched by water from the rivers like Machakund, Sileru, Potteru, Saptadhara-Kolab-Saveri which originate from mountains of Koraput.
Had Orissa government been serious on protesting against Polavaram project, it should have started irrigation projects the upstream,” the SODC president said.
Now the State was facing imminent threat of getting affected by Indira Sagar project at Polavaram. “Under present circumstances, leaders irrespective of party lines should get united and oppose the project,” he said.
Similarly, although Indravati was flowing in many parts of Nabrangpur district, agriculture there remained dependant on rain, Mr. Sahoo said. He said the Orissa government was not focusing its attention on preventing water from flowing into Andhra Pradesh and Chhattisgarh.
Situation was similar on rivers such as Mahendratanaya, Jhanjavati and Vanshadhara, Mr. Sahoo sai.d
Wednesday, September 1, 2010
'Flooding' Investments
Traditionally unheard of, flood has become a regular feature in these rivers, thanks to our river managers and decision makers. These man-made floods are the result of diversion of Indravati water, which after power production, flows to the narrow-channel of the Hati, subsequently draining to the Tel. It is a fact that it is the water of Indravati that is causing flash floods in these rivers of late.
The arrogance and shortsightedness of the mainstream river management paradigm is clearly evident in this example, where at one point, investment is made to cause flood (by diverting water) and then further investment is justified at another point to control flood. Is it a sheer coincidence that while both the interventions suit engineers, contractors and politicians, it is the people who suffer - be it the downstream inhabitants of Indravati suffering from water exclusion or the communities in the river banks of Hati, Tel and Udanti facing flash floods.
Who are our rivers for any way?
Floods: River embankments to be strengthened
Express News Service
First Published : 31 Aug 2010 08:57:30 AM IST
Last Updated :
BHUBANESWAR: The State Government has decided to strengthen the embankment of the Tel, the Hati and the Udanti rivers to deal with the flash floods in Kalahandi and Nabarangpur districts.
The total length of the embankments is 54 km. Official sources said that ` 90 crore would be required for strengthening the embankments. A decision was taken to request National Bank for Agriculture and Rural Development (NABARD) for financial assistance to implement the project.
A decision to this effect was taken at a high-level meeting presided over by Revenue and Disaster Management Minister Surjya Narayan Patro at the Secretariat today.
For strengthening of embankment at vulnerable points ` 3 crore will be needed out of which the Water Resources Department will provide ` 1 crore and ` 2 crore will be made available by the Revenue Department. Apart from strengthening of the embankments, the submergible culvert near Junagarh over the Hati river on NH-201 will be replaced by a high-level bridge. The project will be undertaken by the Works Department.
Among others, Secretaries of Rural Development, Water Resources, Revenue and senior officials were present.
The arrogance and shortsightedness of the mainstream river management paradigm is clearly evident in this example, where at one point, investment is made to cause flood (by diverting water) and then further investment is justified at another point to control flood. Is it a sheer coincidence that while both the interventions suit engineers, contractors and politicians, it is the people who suffer - be it the downstream inhabitants of Indravati suffering from water exclusion or the communities in the river banks of Hati, Tel and Udanti facing flash floods.
Who are our rivers for any way?
Floods: River embankments to be strengthened
Express News Service
First Published : 31 Aug 2010 08:57:30 AM IST
Last Updated :
BHUBANESWAR: The State Government has decided to strengthen the embankment of the Tel, the Hati and the Udanti rivers to deal with the flash floods in Kalahandi and Nabarangpur districts.
The total length of the embankments is 54 km. Official sources said that ` 90 crore would be required for strengthening the embankments. A decision was taken to request National Bank for Agriculture and Rural Development (NABARD) for financial assistance to implement the project.
A decision to this effect was taken at a high-level meeting presided over by Revenue and Disaster Management Minister Surjya Narayan Patro at the Secretariat today.
For strengthening of embankment at vulnerable points ` 3 crore will be needed out of which the Water Resources Department will provide ` 1 crore and ` 2 crore will be made available by the Revenue Department. Apart from strengthening of the embankments, the submergible culvert near Junagarh over the Hati river on NH-201 will be replaced by a high-level bridge. The project will be undertaken by the Works Department.
Among others, Secretaries of Rural Development, Water Resources, Revenue and senior officials were present.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)